Are Relationships Predestined? They are in China!

important business relationshiosYuánfèn  (缘分) is a common term often heard among the local Chinese and is  strongly tied to the idea of relationships in China, both personal and business. As discussed in a previous article on relationships, in China there is a strong emphasis placed on building and maintaining networks of personal and business relationships. Beyond the fundamental importance of relationship networks in China, the idea of Yuánfèn can represent an even deeper meaning for many Chinese. Through this somewhat ambiguous yet important term, many Chinese people come to believe that some relationships contain a touch of destiny, and as a result this can lead to even greater commitment with regard to certain relationships.

However, due to the many cultural and language gaps between China and Western countries, Yuánfèn is not a term that many Western business people are familiar with. Even if Westerners have heard the term, they often do not fully understand its significance. The following article details some of the specific points relating to Yuánfèn in China, as well as how Western expatriates can best apply them to their lives and businesses.

 Defining Yuánfèn (缘分

Although the term Yuánfèn is ambiguous and has many different interpretations, there are several meanings that hold more weight than others.    Yuán (缘) by itself means karma or fate; the second character Fèn(分) can mean the division between two halves. When combined together the term Yuánfèn (缘分) can be defined in the following ways:

  1. A relationship that has been predestined
  2. Fate or chance that brings (two or more) people together
  3. A predestined affinity (with a person, place, etc.)

While much of the information available about Yuánfèn through popular sources, including the internet, pertains chiefly to its application in the areas of love and romance, it is important to be aware that Yuánfèn can be applied to any type of relationship. These additional areas can include relationships of the personal, business, and political persuasions.  Additionally, in colloquial language it is not unheard of for the Chinese to use the term Yuánfèn to describe their relationship (or lack thereof) with a country, custom, or habit. For example, Westerners with a great love of China might choose to remark that they “have Yuánfèn with China.” In contrast, a Chinese person who has had to give up smoking may comment that he or she “has no Yuánfèn with cigarettes.”

 The Origins of Yuánfèn 

buddhism and yuanfen

The origin of the Chinese concept of Yuánfèn comes from an ancient Chinese and Asian idea that two people can be drawn inexorably together through an innate connection in the universe. And although this concept can, especially when translated incorrectly, be construed as akin to the English concept of “destiny,” there are  several important distinctions. First, the inevitability of this link does not in fact derive from any god-like figure as Westerners might understand it. Second, it focuses more specifically on two people sharing a strong bond which draws them together, and does not necessarily relate to what they may or may not be fated to accomplish together.

A large part of the significance of Yuánfèn draws upon ideas inherent in the Buddhist faith which has long been prevalent in Chinese culture. Practitioners of Buddhism believe that all living things are reincarnated at the end of their lives to lead new lives on Earth. By itself the probability of two people coming together in a world of over seven billion (or a in country of over 1.3 billion Chinese) is significantly low. When one considers the possibility that two individuals might go through countless incarnations on earth before finally chancing a meeting would make such a meeting (and relationship) even more special and profound.

 Yuánfèn in China Today: Business, Friendships, and Romance

Relationships in chinaFor friends in China, Yuánfèn can be that special element that determines a lifelong friendship. As there is not really a reliable method to determine whether or not there is truly an innate connection between two people, the Chinese chiefly rely on common backgrounds, interests, and their emotional impressions to let them know whether or not they feel they have Yuánfèn with a specific person. For example, if two individuals working in the big city meet, and upon conversing discover that they are from the same small town they might feel as if they have Yuánfèn. This would be especially true if they met by chance on multiple occasions.

One common, if non-business related, area in Chinese society in which Yuanfen is often encountered is in romantic relationships. Two people who meet by chance or through a certain set of circumstances, and thereafter find that they possess strong feelings for each other, often believe that their meeting was the will of the universe. However, being fated to be drawn together and being fated to end up together do not necessarily go hand in hand. The Chinese have a saying in this regard, yǒu yuán wú fèn (有缘无分). It means that although two people might have been fated to meet, in the end they were not destined to remain together. It is a saying  commonly used in China when one person wishes to break up with another.

Perhaps more important to the Western businessperson is Yuánfèn’s potential to influence and affect the formation of important personal and business relationships. Despite an overt focus by younger Chinese people on Yuánfèn’s romantic implications, there are many Chinese within the business community that think of the idea of Yuánfèn when meeting new contacts. Through upbringing and societal structure many Chinese, especially older ones, will hold key contacts  close to their chests, a silo separate and protected from the outside world. If they say they have Yuánfèn with you, they may be tentatively offering you the opportunity to have a stronger personal relationship with you. This in turn can lead to more business opportunities down the road.

What Does This Mean for Westerners?

While the idea of Yuánfèn does not directly affect the way the Chinese go about forming and maintaining relationships, it can certainly offer fresh insights into the thought process that a Chinese person is subject to when meeting new people. From the concept of Yuánfèn, not only do the Chinese believe that two people can be brought together by fate, but also that they will be. Thus many Chinese will over the course of their lives be on the lookout for those special or gifted individuals with whom they can or are fated to develop close connections. In contrast to Westerners who are used to getting to know people over a length of time, especially in the workplace, Chinese people may be prone to make much quicker decisions. If a Chinese business person meets someone with whom he or she shares  common business interests,  hobbies, or an emotional connection, they may make a very quick decision to extend their friendship to that person. Likewise, if a Chinese business person gets a bad impression from someone, they may be much quicker to cut all contact or decide against that person in a specific matter. Understand of course that the Chinese people in general are still very friendly and hospitable to Westerners. The concept of Yuánfèn does not usually affect the normal course of forming friends or business relationships. It will however affect who the Chinese choose to form especially close and trusting relationships with.

Additionally, as the Chinese economy and society continue to develop, the concept of Yuánfèn may remain more relevant to smaller portions of the overall population . And as Yuánfèn is strongly connected to the concept of relationships in China, Yuánfèn will then continue to matter the most where relationships play a greater role in Chinese business and society. This means inland areas far away from the modern metropolises (e.g. Beijing and Shanghai), and  in local industries dominated mostly or solely by Chinese players (e.g. government and Baijiu/sorgum liquor manufacturers) who rely on strong regional and national relationship networks. Age can also be a factor; in the author’s experience it was much more common for Chinese business people born in the 1980’s or earlier to refer to or believe in the concept of Yuánfèn as it might relate to their life or business. Younger Chinese workers, especially those with experience in the West, may not put much, if any, stock in Yuánfèn in the workplace.

To summarize, while Western business people will not be able to count on Yuánfèn in all their dealings with the Chinese, it is by no means something that can be discounted entirely. And because many Chinese use their emotions in part to decide on Yuánfèn, it’s important for Westerners to always try and put on their best face. One can never know when too casual an attitude or too direct an approach can cause discomfort to the Chinese and spoil a potentially rewarding and beneficial relationship. 

Thanks for reading!

Do you have any additional questions on how Yuánfèn can be applied in China? Do you have any interesting experiences with regard to Yuánfèn that you would like to share? Please feel free to post your thoughts in the comments section below.

Follow the China Culture Corner to receive regular updates by email!

Advertisements


Categories: Culture & Society

Tags: , , , , ,

19 replies

  1. Hi Sean…….well the Taiwan trip was worthwhile……I have a few new Chinese friends but the romance recipe was nullified by DUTY……..we are friends……& it was a learning experience for both of us.
    Being the optimist that I am, I am now (as soon as my Chinese Visa arrives) set to take off for Mainland China to be with my new lady.(I am not a Butterfly !)……this one REALLY ticks ALL the box`s…we sing to each other on Skype video each night……..I thank God Face Book is not allowed in China….that was one big reason that Taiwan didn`t work out.(many online “Friends”) no real life…..except for DUTY to Mother…..which I strongly applaud.but it can be suffocating for relationships…….my new love also believes in Yuanfen & we have much in common (a good foundation)…….so please wish me well as I wish all the readers of your site.

    Like

  2. Dear Sean,

    The article is very interesting and the discussion very fascinating. Especially the debate regarding the role of the influence of Buddhist culture in China.
    I wanted to know more about the picture of the thangka painting of Buddha Amitabha you used in the article.

    Could you please tell me where did you get the picture? If you have more info regarding the museum or gallery hosting the painting please contact our thangka school.

    Thank you.

    Like

    • Thanks for commenting and I’m glad you enjoyed the article.

      I’m sorry to say I do not have any additional information on the picture used in the article. If you happen to run across any information on your own, feel free to let me know.

      Like

  3. Yo Sean & others,
    I`ve just returned from Taiwan & meeting my lady & I`d like to report that Yuanfen is still alive….we were completely at ease with each other & were told by old & young that we were a perfect couple…….especially a couple of older Chinese women when we visited 101 Tower who insisted on having their photos taken with me……my lady plans to come to me in Sept. but there is an aged mother in the mix & nothing further can be planned `til she go`s to Paradise………don`t question things……just BELIEVE & go with the flow.

    Like

  4. Because communication is now instant & travel is so much quicker (& becoming more so),the world is SHRINKING & so we are ALL on a collision course………how many times have you been many miles from home or in another country & BINGO…run into a neighbour,workmate,friend or relative…..Hmmmmmm.

    Like

  5. A mature age Taiwanese woman found me on FB & as it turns out we are a perfect match in Chinese Astrology (her Fire Dog…me Earth Tiger also her Capricorn & me Virgo……her a 4…me a 9)…….we both believe GOD ? brought us together & after FB`ing for 3 months I fly to her in 2 days time…..we are both considered by friends to be ecccentric…as it turned out I know her English teacher…….bit of a language problem but we can even sing together (in English)
    Anyway thanks for the blog re Yuanfen & we`ll KNOW when we are face to face………MTFBWY (Star Wars)

    Like

  6. I am Chinese, Chinese people do believe Yuan Fen, it is all from Buddhism. You said something that is not true. Yuanfen usually is used when meeting someone or some people, if they liked each other a lot, they do believe it is all fate. Nothing about other things. Nothing about objects. Only with people.

    Like

    • Thanks for commenting Helen, and thanks for sharing your perspective. However during my experience in China I have encountered people that do indeed associate Yuanfen with things other than people. So perhaps the idea of Yuanfen has evolved differently in different parts of China, or perhaps over time.

      Thanks again!

      Like

  7. I’ve never heard of yuánfèn, but this is a great summary into the subject. I’ll definitely be talking about this with my Chinese friends!

    Like

    • Mike, thanks for the comment. On one hand if your friends are of the younger generation they may not believe much in Yuanfen especially if they have spent a sizable amount of time overseas. On the other hand Yuanfen can be very interesting to talk about for those that do believe in it. Just the other day I was chatting with a Chinese friend who believed Yuanfen played a big role in their first job out of college.

      Like

  8. Well done Sean, nice blog and a very insightful post. I am the only foreigner in a 12,000 employee Chinese company and a 700,000 pop. town, and I find that after several years here, it only gets more and more complicated. Keep up the good work!

    Like

    • Jake, thanks for the comment. I previously worked in a similar situation to yours and I definitely sympathize with you on the complexities of working for small town local Chinese companies. And while learning all about how to apply Chinese culture can certainly make one’s life easier, in my experience it most important to make sure all the managers and executives in the company understand and accept the value the Westerner brings to the company. Once that is accomplished there is less resistance.

      Has your experience been similar?

      Also, have you had opportunities to observe how concepts like Guanxi and Yuanfen affect a Chinese company’s working environment?

      Like

  9. Yes I believe in yuanfen whether it is relationship, friends, work or business
    If you are destined to work with certain person, it can even happen by default. And even after you left there is affinity with the persom

    Like

  10. very informative

    Like

    • Thanks! I appreciate the comment. Chinese culture can be hard to grasp at first for Westerners, and I hope my efforts on this site can make things easier for all. For future comments, please feel free to use your social media accounts (e.g. twitter or facebook).

      Like

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: